Ranking Every Toronto Maple Leafs Starting Goalie Since the 90s
By James Tanner
2010-11
Jean Sebastian G. and Jonas G. were joined by James Reimer. Big surprise they missed the playoffs again with this set of jokers.
2011-12
Again, it’s not hard to see where the Leafs went wrong in the Burke years. Again we have Jonas Gustavsson playing half the games. Jussi Rynas played 2, Ben Scrivens 12 and James Reimer played 34 times.
2012-13
Another lockout, another crap Leafs team led by brutal goalies. This one actually did make the playoffs, but you know they didn’t win any rounds. Again it’s Reimer, Scrivens, and Rynas.
2013-14
The Leafs picked up noted intellectual Jonathan Bernier for this season, and despite not knowing who Nelson Mandela was, he was still smarter than Reimer, who was still here. Also Drew McIntyre played two games.
2014-15
The rare instance of getting through the season with two goalies occurred here for the first time since the 2001-02 series. Bernier and Reimer played every game, and unsurprisingly, the Leafs missed the playoffs.
2015-16
James Reimer, Jon Bernier, Garrett Sparks. Huzza!
2016-17
For the first time in over a decade, the Leafs employ an actual goalie – welcome to Toronto Mr. Freddie Andersen, and in retrospect we shoulda never let you go.
Antoine Bibeau, Curtis McElhinney and Jonas Entroth filled out the lineup.
2017-18
Joining Andersen and McElhinney this year was Calvin Pickard (for one game).
2018-19
Andersen was joined by our old friend Michael Hutchinson, and after a two-year hiatus, Garrett Sparks played 20 games.
2019-20
It was Freddie Andersen was joined by Jack Campbell, and Michael Hutchinson, as well as Kasimir Kaskisuo.
2020-21
Once again, it was Freddie, Jack, and Michael H. This time joined by David Rittich for four games.
2021-22
Jack Campbell was joined by Peter Mrazek. In addition, Joseph Woll, Erik Kalggren and Michael Hutchinson all played games too.
2022-23
You remember this year as the year the Leafs finally won a series in the playoffs. Also, it was just a month ago!!!!
Ilya Samsonov, Matt Murray, Joseph Woll, Erik Kallgren were joined by emergency goalie Jett Alexander, who as far as I can tell, is the only emergency goalie to play for the Toronto Maple Leafs since 1990.