Editor In Leaf
Fansided

Top 10 Toronto Maple Leafs Goaltenders of All-Time

ByMike Jack|
TORONTO, ON - JANUARY 05: Statues of former Toronto Maple Leafs goalies Johnny Bower and Turk Broda enshrined in Legends Row outside the Air Canada Centre before the Toronto Raptors game against the Utah Jazz during NBA game action at Air Canada Centre on January 5, 2017 in Toronto, Canada. NOTE TO USER: User expressly acknowledges and agrees that, by downloading and or using this photograph, User is consenting to the terms and conditions of the Getty Images License Agreement. (Photo by Tom Szczerbowski/Getty Images)
TORONTO, ON - JANUARY 05: Statues of former Toronto Maple Leafs goalies Johnny Bower and Turk Broda enshrined in Legends Row outside the Air Canada Centre before the Toronto Raptors game against the Utah Jazz during NBA game action at Air Canada Centre on January 5, 2017 in Toronto, Canada. NOTE TO USER: User expressly acknowledges and agrees that, by downloading and or using this photograph, User is consenting to the terms and conditions of the Getty Images License Agreement. (Photo by Tom Szczerbowski/Getty Images)
2 of 11
Toronto Maple Leafs
PHILADELPHIA, PA – JANUARY 19: James Reimer #34 of the Toronto Maple Leafs in action against the Philadelphia Flyers at Wells Fargo Center on January 19, 2016 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Patrick Smith/Getty Images)

Honourable Mentions for Top Toronto Maple Leafs Goalies of All Time

Paul Bibeault 1943-44
2nd Team All-Star 1944
Ranked #2 in NHL GAA 1943-44 (3.00)

Bruce Gamble 1965-1971
Played in 1968 NHL All-Star Game
2nd Best Single Season SV% in  Leafs History (.934 in 1967-68)
7th Best Single Season SV% in NHL History (.934 in 1967-68)
7th Best Toronto Maple Leafs Career SV% in History (.914)
Ranked #1 in NHL SV% 1967-68 (.934)
Ranked #6 in NHL SV% 1968-69 (.914)
Ranked #9 in NHL SV% 1969-70 (.915)
Ranked #4 in NHL GAA 1967-68 (2.32)
Ranked #8 in NHL GAA 1968-69 (2.81)

Frederik Andersen 2016-2021
4th in Vezina Trophy voting 2018
10th in Vezina Trophy voting 2019
7th in Team All-Star voting 2019
11th in Team All-Star voting 2018
12th in Team All-Star voting 2020
Played in 2020 NHL All-Star Game
7th Best Toronto Maple Leafs Career SV% in History (.914)

John Roach 1921-28
Stanley Cup Champion 1922
Best Toronto Maple Leafs Career GAA in History (2.01)
6th Best Single Season GAA in Toronto Maple Leafs History (1.98 in 1927-28)
8th Best Single Season GAA in Toronto Maple Leafs History (2.04 in 1926-27)
Ranked #3 in NHL GAA 1921-22 (4.07)
Ranked #3 in NHL GAA 1922-23 (3.59)
Ranked #4 in NHL GAA 1923-24 (3.48)
Ranked #5 in NHL GAA 1924-25 (2.80)

Doug Favell 1973-74
Ranked #4 in NHL SV% 1973-74 (.909)
Ranked #3 in NHL GAA 1973-74 (2.71)

Ed Chadwick 1955-60
2nd in Calder Memorial Trophy voting 1957
Ranked #4 in NHL SV% 1958-59 (.905)
Ranked #4 in NHL GAA 1958-59 (2.97)
Ranked #5 in NHL GAA 1956-57 (2.66)

Don Simmons 1961-64
Ranked #1 in NHL GAA 1962-63 (2.47)

Frank McCool 1944-1946
Calder Memorial Trophy Winner 1945
Stanley Cup Champion 1945
Ranked #3 in NHL GAA 1944-45 (3.22)

Lorne Chabot 1928-33
Stanley Cup Champion 1932
Best Single Season GAA in Toronto Maple Leafs History (1.52 in 1928-29)
9th Best Single Season GAA in Toronto Maple Leafs History (2.09 in 1930-31)
16th Best Single Season GAA in NHL History (1.52 in 1928-29)
4th Best Toronto Maple Leafs Career GAA in History (2.16)
Ranked #5 in NHL GAA 1929-30 (2.54)

James Reimer 2010-16
23rd in Hart Memorial Trophy voting 2013
15th in Calder Memorial Trophy voting 2011
22nd in Lady Byng Memorial Trophy voting 2011
7th in Team All-Star voting 2013
7th Best Single Season SV% in Toronto Maple Leafs History (.924 in 2013-14)
8th Best Single Season SV% in Toronto Maple Leafs History (.922 in 2015-16)
13th Best Single Season SV% in Toronto Maple Leafs History (.921 in 2010-11)
7th Best Toronto Maple Leafs Career SV% in History (.914)
Ranked #7 in NHL SV% 2015‑16 (.922)
Ranked #8 in NHL SV% 2012‑13 (.924)

Get ready for your Top 10 Toronto Maple Leafs Goalies of All Time!

Home/All-Time Lists