If an Auston Matthews trade were ever to happen, it would not be anytime soon. Matthews still has two seasons remaining on his contract, which carries a $13.25 million AAV and includes a full no-movement clause. Simply put, Matthews controls his future. If he wants to remain in Toronto and eventually sign a long-term extension, the organization has little reason or ability to move him. In fact, doing so would be organizational wrongdoing. Matthews is not a player you trade; he is a player you build around.
A slower season, not a decline
Matthews has admittedly struggled to produce at the elite pace fans are accustomed to. The departure of Mitch Marner this summer removed his most consistent offensive partner, forcing Matthews to adapt on the fly. Under Craig Berube, the Leafs have shifted toward a more structured, defensive style of hockey. Games are tighter, lower scoring, and far less high scoring than in years past. That change has required Matthews to invest more defensively, limiting some of the offensive freedom he once had.
This evolution does not signal regression; it signals adjustment. Every superstar endures stretches like this, but in Toronto, every goal and point drought is magnified. Matthews is learning how to dominate in a new system while still finding ways to score at an elite level. Auston Matthews is on a hot streak, regaining fans' trust and building his own confidence.
Legacy still within reach
Even during a “down” season, Matthews is on the verge of history. He sits fifth on the Leafs’ all-time points list, just over 200 points shy of Mats Sundin, and is only five goals away from becoming the franchise’s all-time leading goal scorer. If Matthews commits long-term, he has a legitimate chance to go down as the greatest Maple Leaf of all time.
Encouraging signs are already there. Over the past few games, his shot has looked quicker and more dangerous, particularly in Sunday’s matchup against Detroit. The goals will come and come frequently. From management’s perspective, there is no wavering confidence. The Maple Leafs staff named Matthews captain for a reason. The Leafs are not looking to move on; they are trusting their leader to guide them forward. With patience, the payoff will come.