The Toronto Maple Leafs recently sent Nicholas Robertson down to the AHL to make room for the return of Calle Jarnkrok from LTIR.
The demotion was not performance based, but rather because Robertson is the only member of the Toronto Maple Leafs, other than first liner Matthew Knies, who is eligible to be send to the AHL without first having to clear waivers.
The Leafs used the fact that Robertson doesn't need to clear waivers to their advantage, but is it a fair to Robertson when he's won his minutes and put up decent numbers in a limited role during his rookie season?
Robertson is having his healthiest and most productive season as a pro. He has eight goals and 11 assists for 19 points in 41 games. That's not too bad for a player averaging 11:22 minutes of ice time. However, many people, including myself, want to see more from Robertson. (All stats from hockey-reference.com)
Toronto Maple Leafs Should Trade Nicholas Robertson
According to Elliotte Friedman from Sportsnet, Robertson received confirmation from the Leafs that this recent demotion will not last long. The Leafs assured him that they intend to call him back up to the NHL soon. Regardless of the Leafs assurances, the situation has to be frustrating for Robertson. I will admit that I don't think Robertson gets enough playing time to really showcase his ability, and he has arguably earned it by not only scoring at a 5v5 rate comprable to William Nylander, but playing well enough that the Leafs are winning his minutes whether you measure them by puck possesion, shots, scoring chances, dangerous scoring chances, goals or expected goals. (Naturalstattrick.com).
Robertson will become a restricted free agent at the end of this season. It is hard to imagine him wanting to re-sign with the Leafs unless they intend on playing him regularly. As the NHL creeps closer to the trade deadline, I wouldn't rule out a trade involving Robertson leaving the Leafs.
The Leafs general manager, Brad Treliving, has made it clear that the Leafs would prefer not to trade prospects Easton Cowan or Fraser Minten. That leaves Robertson, Ryan Tverberg, Topi Niemela, and the 2024 first-round pick as the Leafs best trading chips.
I believe that Robertson has been surpassed by Matthew Knies and Bobby McMann this season. Now, if I had to choose between re-signing McMann (UFA) or Robertson (RFA), I would re-sign McMann. I have no idea what Treliving's plans for the Leafs are, but if he doesn't see a future for Robertson with the Leafs, trading him is the best option.
Trelving should try to package Robertson with the 2024 first-round pick to try and acquire a top pairing right-shooting defenseman. Morgan Rielly needs an elite defense partner and getting one will be costly. I like the addition of Lyubushkin, but he's not a top-pairing guy.
Treliving has until 3:00 pm this Friday to make a deal. We will find out by Friday night if Robertson is still a member of the Leafs organization or not.