Third Pick
Their third pick came in the fourth round, 110th overall where the Leafs selected WHL goaltender Ian Scott, one slot before the rival Boston Bruins took Jeremy Swayman.
Ouch!
Scott was the starting netminder behind a fairly poor and rebuilding Prince Albert Raiders team. Despite this, he was fifth with an .895 SV% amongst draft eligible goalies in the WHL and only one of two starters.
Over the next few seasons, his numbers improved along with the team. So much so that Scott lead the Raiders to a WHL championship in 2019. That season saw him win Playoffs MVP, WHL top goaltender, and CHL goaltender of the year awards.
By this time Scott had pushed himself into the conversation of an exciting goalie prospect. He may not have had the pedigree like Team Canada’s WJC starter or a high pick but he seemed to be trending toward a possible NHL future.
Unfortunately, before his pro career could even start, Scott would be sidelined for six months following hip surgery. It would eventually become the full season due to the Covid-19 pandemic.
The following season Scott would once again battle injuries and only play six games between the AHL and ECHL. Then in 2021-22 Scott would once again battle injuries, only playing one game with the Newfoundland Growlers.
After that season ended, Scott would announce his retirement from hockey at the age of 23.
This was starting to look like a good pick before the injuries set in, so this wasn't bad drafting, just bad luck.