The Best and Worst Value Contracts Among Toronto Maple Leafs Defensemen

The Leafs have restocked their defense. With the blue line mostly complete, which players provide the best return on their deal?

Toronto Maple Leafs vs. Carolina Hurricanes
Toronto Maple Leafs vs. Carolina Hurricanes | Jaylynn Nash/GettyImages
3 of 5

Worst Value Contract on the Leafs Defense

There is the potential for more defensemen to fall into this category, but for now, the dubious distinction goes to Ekman-Larsson.

The AAV of $3.5 million is acceptable (109th league-wide), but a four-year commitment carries great risk. Ekman-Larsson looked on the verge of playing his way out of the league during his last years with the Arizona Coyotes and his couple of seasons with the Vancouver Canucks.

The Leafs gave him a raise of over 50% and a three-year commitment even though last year he played the same role and had the same statistics as Mark Giordano, who they paid only $800 K.

He found a new life with the Cup-champion Florida Panthers, however, was he insulated by the strong team around him?

Of course he was. He won his minutes playing on the third pairing in a sheltered role, and parlayed a Stanely Cup win into an ill-advised raise and promotion.

His value comes from moving the puck and helping out offensively. He will have limited effectiveness If he doesn't mesh with the Maple Leafs stars at forward. His age is another red flag.

Even if he earns and succeeds in a top-four role, that means Jake McCabe will have less value because he'll either be on the third pairing or the right side.

Schedule