Jerry Lai-USA TODAY Sports

Toronto Maple Leafs Daily Poll: If You Were Dave Nonis, What Would You Do?

Well, as one broadcaster on Sportsnet said yesterday, ‘the 18-wheeler might be pulling out of the garage’.

With yesterday’s 6-1 drubbing from the Carolina Hurricanes, the Toronto Leafs big win in the Winter Classic seems like ages ago. The Leafs are now tied with the Hurricanes and the New York Rangers for the second wild card and final playoff spot in the Eastern Conference. We can longer say that other teams are catching up to the Leafs, because they’ve been caught.

The Leafs are now out of playoff spot for the first time this season because of a tie-breaker. They have been out-scored 18-5 combined in their games since the Winter Classic. The Leafs are obviously heading in the wrong direction.

So what does Leafs general manager Dave Nonis do?

Does he leave everything as it is? Hope the current team and coach fight out of the funk that they’re in right now. That would certainly be a risk and if the Leafs fail this season because Nonis did nothing, then it’s Nonis’ head on the chopping block.

Does he make a trade or two? There have been plenty of rumors, mostly surrounding young players like Nazem Kadri and Jake Gardiner. For the Leafs to trade those players, the return would have to be a very good one. Maybe that type of big shake-up is what the Leafs need right now.

Finally, does he fire the coach?

Randy Carlyle has had an easy time as Leafs coach for the most part when it comes to fans. Of course, he was only around for 18 games in the 2011-12 season and got the Leafs to the playoffs in the lockout-shortened 2012-13 season.

This year started off rather well so it looked like Carlyle would stay in the fan’s good graces. However, with the teams now’ three month slide, he has certainly fallen out of the fan’s good books. Could a pink slip from his boss soon follow?

This is certainly an interesting, if not disappointing, time to be a Leafs fan?


If You Were Dave Nonis, What Would You Do?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Tags: Dave Nonis Randy Carlyle Toronto Maple Leafs

4 Comments on Toronto Maple Leafs Daily Poll: If You Were Dave Nonis, What Would You Do?

  1. Celtic Sparky says:

    Dave Nonis should fire Dave Nonis. Leafs should have hired a GM who had a fresh perspective on the team rather than signing Burke favourites Kessel and Phaneuf to long term contracts. In comparison with other teams such as the Blues the Leafs have done a terrible job in assessing player talent and will remain a mediocre team.

    • Tim Bayer says:

      The problems stem from Carlyle. Nonis got rid of the players Carlyle doesn’t like and brought in players he likes, and the team has gotten so much worse. All the while Carlyle has run this team into the ground with his horrible coaching methods. Fire Carlyle.

    • Tommy Ryan says:

      1 Dave Nonis is not doing anything wrong,I think it’s Carlyle who is not focusing on improving their defence or their game play at all, I think he wants them to play 2007 Randy Carlyle Style hockey which clearly they can’t do I say fire Carlyle, 2. St.Louis has a really great team and their doing really well, and 3.once the Leafs can make a few trades and get something better than what they have I think they will have a pretty good team they just need to figure it out

      • Tim Bayer says:

        There are some pieces (Kessel, JvR, Kadri, Lupul, Gardiner, Phaneuf, Rielly, Reimer, Bernier) in place. It’s just a matter of evaluating the talent correctly and making the necessary changes. I don’t think either Carlyle or Nonis have shown the ability to do that.

Join The Discussion